I thought I knew a lot about patisserie until I stumbled upon canelés de bordeaux for the first time and realized I really must know nothing if I could have possibly missed something so wonderful. Then I realized that canelés aren’t really as common as so many other more familiar patisserie items particularly because they are challenging to bake successfully. But the optimist in me, blinded by my immediate addiction to the marvelous little cakes, thought that if I couldn’t find canelés at the local bakery I’d make them myself.
Heaps of cookbooks are published every year. And people must be buying them or they wouldn’t go to the trouble to print them. But it is not so clear that they’re using them to cook, as opposed to merely engaging in food spectating. If a cookbook is essentially a set of instructions, its appeal is predicated on a person’s assumption that they’re capable of actually making the recipes it includes. It is all very much in keeping with the entrepreneurial American “do it yourself” spirit. Sometimes though you have to be man enough to admit when something is beyond your ability. This is one of those instances.
My first encounter with canelés was a revelation: tiny fluted cakes that fit in the palm of your hand... their shiny golden crust the perfect combination of a crispy/chewy wall that you bite through before you get to the eggy, custardy center infused with vanilla and rum. I knew I was blessed to discover them but then immediately realized I was cursed because I hooked and wanted more. It was fortunate that one of the best bakeries in all of Seattle was located only a few blocks from my house. But despite their product line that includes upwards of 150 items, they did not make canelés. In fact, few bakeries did. An intelligent person would have taken that as a sign. I did not.
Days later I was already online doing research on these perfect little cakes. Their legend apparently stretched back for centuries. I found an apocryphal story about how they originated near docks where they were made them with the flour spilled from cargo ships. Others had them originating in monasteries. In early iterations they had been more bread-like and were probably fried. As only the French could, rules were applied to define the proper cooking methods and correct appellation of the little cakes. Less evidence is available as to how they migrated to their current cooking methods. And that was most interesting.
In order to achieve that wonderful combination of golden exterior and custardy interior, the canelés are cooked in special tin-lined, copper molds. As if that wasn’t enough, a special mixture of butter and edible beeswax is used to line the interior of the molds, acting as a releasing agent. I was intrigued by the challenge of the obscure equipment and the many mentions I discovered of the tricky process. But making my own continued to seem like the best way I was going to get a steady supply. So I began to look around for what I would need to make it happen.
There were silicone molds available. And their price was inflated owing to the relative expense of the copper which was the only other viable option. As the silicone did not require the beeswax/butter formula I judged it to be less authentic and focused only on procuring the copper molds. There didn’t seem to be any used molds being offered anywhere. So I bought (for around $120) six brand-new copper molds from Mauviel, a company that had been making copper cookware in France since the 1830’s. Once they arrived I had to season them by brushing oil on their tin interiors and placing them on a baking sheet which went into a 350 degree oven for an hour.
Then I set about finding a suitable recipe. There were dozens online. It seemed like basically a crepe batter of milk, eggs, vanilla, sugar, butter, flour and a little bit of rum. Most of the recipes recommended making the batter and allowing it to chill and rest over night in the fridge.
The food-quality beeswax and clarified butter was mixed in equal proportion in a sauce pan with much care (considering that it was essentially fuel that seems to burn very well in candles). The result resembled a less viscous, milky beeswax. And it was from here that I began to go wrong. I had seasoned the molds a few days prior and hadn’t thought about pre-heating them before the actual baking. As I brushed the beeswax/butter emulsion into the molds it cooled much too rapidly and was ultimately a much thicker layer than I needed. I wouldn’t figure this out until it was too late.
With my molds lined with the beeswax, the batter was poured in until each mold was about 3/4 full. The canelés were put into a hot oven (over 400 degrees) and cooked for more than an hour, which is needed to give the cakes their dark, golden brown “shell” which would encase the delicate custard. I had read somewhere that the tops of the cakes might rise above the rim and then sink down again, which they did. But the cooking time was variable. It was different for every recipe I found. And warnings about not rushing the process were widespread too. So there was a bit of hand-wringing and equivocation about the timing. The most troublesome development was that it seemed the wax mixture had melted and bubbled to the top of the molds during baking.
I finally decided the very dark cakes should come out. They needed to cool but I was anxious to know if I was successful. So I took one of the molds off the rack after only a short time, inverted it, and was disappointed when it did not slip out of the mold cleanly. In fact, it didn’t slip out at all. I used wooden skewers to poke and prod at the insides of the mold until the canelé came out... in pieces.
My experiment was unsuccessful. The center was slightly moist and custardy, but was mostly a sad, deflated blob. The outside was too dark. Not quite burned but well-beyond the delicious golden stage. What’s worse is that there was a thick, unappetizing wax layer on the outside that coated your mouth in an extremely unpleasant way. I knew that even if I had allowed the other cakes to cool the results would probably be the same.
I’ve talked with a few people after this experience and what I’ve discovered is that few succeed at their first attempt to bake this temperamental little cake. And I guess that I may have succeeded if I kept at it. But I decided it wasn’t worth it for me, just from that fact that it took me forever to clean all of the wax out of the molds to reset them. It was just too much trouble for too low a percentage of success. The best news was that I listed my expensive seasoned canelés molds on eBay and was delighted when they sold at a tidy profit. I’ll be using the proceeds to buy some canelés at Honoré Artisan Bakery in Ballard.